How This Popular Trade Regime Is Setting You Up for Disaster
In the ever-shifting world of international trade, navigating customs procedures can often feel like you are trying to outwit a bureaucratic maze that has no end. Many have found shipping into Europe exactly that. There's one particular shortcut that has caught the eye of many UK businesses looking to sidestep these hurdles when shipping into Europe:
Customs Procedure 42 (CPC 42) or the commonly referred to Regime 42.
Originally designed to streamline the importation process and help companies free up cash flow, Regime 42 offers businesses a way to import goods into the European Union (EU) without paying import VAT. Sounds like a sweet deal, right? The catch, however, is that the more you know about this regime, the more you realise it’s not all smooth sailing.
Why Does Regime 42 Exist?
Regime 42 was introduced in the early 2000’s original as a stimulus to incentivise foreign businesses to begin selling their goods in the EU. It was also part of a larger framework to simplify VAT accounting for businesses importing goods. For the uninitiated, VAT is a hefty upfront cost when importing goods—especially for UK exporters who never accounted for this pre-Brexit.
The Trade Shortcut That Took Off
Since the onset of Brexit, it didn’t take long for UK businesses to see the appeal of Regime 42. With France being the gateway for many UK exports to the EU, it’s no wonder that Regime 42 and France became a go-to mechanism for many. The proximity of key ports like Calais and Le Havre, combined with frequent UK-EU transport routes, made it an attractive proposition for companies trying to avoid tying up cash flow in VAT.
The idea was simple: Import goods into France, immediately transport them to another EU state (Germany, for example), and instead of paying import VAT upfront, you defer it to the country where the goods will be consumed. Cash flow? No problem. But the reality is much more complicated.
But here’s the catch—the reality behind the convenience is a little messier than it first appears.
The Pitfalls: Why Regime 42 Might Not Be the Answer
1. A Red Tape Jungle
French customs authorities are no strangers to scrutiny, and since Brexit, they have ramped up inspections and audits on shipments using Regime 42. The risk of retroactive VAT charges and hefty fines for improper declarations is real. If you cannot prove that the goods are leaving France and heading to their final destination within the EU, the French tax office could very well demand VAT payments—potentially crippling your cash flow and even jeopardising your business.
2. Compliance Risks as Importer of Record (IOR)
Under Regime 42, shipments must still be cleared with the UK-registered business set up as the Importer of Record (IOR). The issue arises when a third party’s EU VAT number is used for VAT postponement, as the IOR is meant to be linked to the local EU VAT number. Tax authorities hold the IOR responsible for VAT payments. If there are compliance issues, improper documentation, or incorrect customs declarations, the tax office will come knocking—on the UK-based IOR’s door—demanding a VAT payment. This could cause serious financial strain due to an improperly structured EU setup.
3. The VAT Number Problem
Using Regime 42 requires a valid VAT number from the final destination country. But here’s the kicker: if you do not get the VAT number right, or if there is any discrepancy in the documentation (such as missing transport proof or an incorrect VAT declaration), the customs declaration could be rejected. In that case, you could end up paying VAT upfront in France anyway—a financial nightmare waiting to happen.
4. Extra Representation Costs
If your business is not VAT-registered in France, you will need a representative—an agent who handles VAT compliance on your behalf. This may sound straightforward, but not every agent is willing to handle Regime 42, especially for non-EU businesses. The ones who do often charge hefty fees or require financial guarantees upfront. Not only does this add complexity, but it also increases costs, making the entire process less attractive.
5. Double VAT Risk
Here’s where things get really complicated. If the declaration process is not executed perfectly, you could end up paying VAT twice: once in France and again in the final destination country. That’s right—double VAT. A costly mistake that most businesses do not anticipate and one that can quickly erode profit margins.
Light At The End of The Tunnel: What Alternatives Are Out There
1. Import Through Your Own VAT-Registered Entity in the EU
Instead of relying on Regime 42, UK businesses can register for VAT in an EU country (e.g., France or the Netherlands) and import goods under their own VAT number while remaining the Importer of record. This ensures complete compliance and allows businesses largely mitigating the risk of unexpected VAT liabilities.
2. Use a VAT Deferment Scheme
Several EU countries, including France, Belgium, and the Netherlands, offer Postponed VAT Accounting equivalents, allowing importers to defer import VAT payment and account for it on their VAT return instead of paying it.
3. No foreign entity or presence is needed
The large kicker – The UK registered business will not have to have an EU entity or physical presence in Europe and this can all be run with a foreign setup, all linked to their UK registered business, while remaining fully within the UK.
The Bottom Line: A Smarter, Safer Approach to EU Imports
While Regime 42 might seem like an attractive shortcut, the compliance risks, administrative headaches, and potential double VAT liabilities make it a dangerous gamble. Instead, UK exporters should consider more stable alternatives such as VAT registration in the EU as well as fiscal representation in VAT-friendly EU countries like the Netherlands. By choosing a compliant route, businesses can avoid financial surprises and ensure smooth trade operations across the EU. If you’re looking for more stable, less risky options, let’s chat. Because, in the world of trade, it’s always better to play it safe than gamble with your bottom line.
Author: GMCC Approved Supplier VAT IT/STREAM
Interested in booking a 121 with our Approved suppliers?
Simply email us at international@gmchamber.co.uk indicating in the subject line: VAT Support.
Comments